• 10/27/26

Episode 31: The Pretend Pros Bowl

One ugly loss, one bragging-rights bet, and one very real question: did Indiana just get sent back to the kids’ table? Beth and Jenny turn their Ohio State vs. Indiana showdown into a high-stakes college football therapy session, complete with scoreboard debates, ranking chaos, and just enough rivalry trash talk.

Beth, the devastated IU fan, breaks down why this game felt bigger than a normal loss, from the late-80s drought to the pressure of finally earning respect. Jenny, the Buckeye fan, revels in the win but admits the margin was razor thin, which makes the postgame arguing even better. Together, they unpack the controversial catch, and why the result still left both fan bases with very different emotions.

You'll hear them get into:

  • Why Indiana fell while Ohio State climbed

  • The wild weekend of upsets across the top 25, including chaos in the SEC

  • Why injuries, bye weeks, and quarterback depth could reshape the weeks ahead

  • The looming Michigan, USC, and conference schedule pressure on both teams

  • What the expanded playoff era means for rankings, bowl games, and recruiting timing

Beth also brings the IU perspective on what it means to finally be relevant again, while Jenny gives the Buckeye side of the rivalry and the confidence that comes with surviving a close one. It is funny, petty, and insightful in the way only true sports-fan friendships can be.

If you care about college football, rivalry energy, ranking drama, or the kind of sports arguments that never fully end, this one is essential listening. Perfect for fans who want to hear what a one-score game can do to two co-hosts who both think they were right.

Previous

Episode 32: World Series Champs, WNBA Finals & MLB Trivia

Next

Episode 30: MLB, WNBA, & College Football Collide in a Massive Sports Week